
Bibb County Schools: The Repair
75 min read
Last updated
Bibb County Watchdog, Part 6 of Six: The Repair
Five parts of this series have taken Bibb County Schools apart, piece by piece. Part 1 followed the money and found a district that has now adopted three straight budgets planning to spend more than it takes in. Part 2 followed the vendors and found contracts that renew themselves out of habit. Part 3 followed the results and found a graduation rate of 89 percent standing next to a proficiency rate of 23 percent, a mirage with a marching band. Part 4 followed the org chart and found fourteen chairs at the top and one known competitive search among them. Part 5 followed the people, into the classrooms where every one of those decisions lands.
Watch the finale film: Bibb County Schools: The Repair.
Diagnosis is not treatment. A watchdog that barks at the wreck and never says how to clear the road is doing half the job, so this final part is the prescription. Some of it is mine, built by inverting the failures the first five parts documented: if a thing is broken in a specific way, the repair is usually the opposite of the break, done on purpose and in public. Some of it is yours. When I asked teachers, retired teachers, parents, and staff what is broken and exactly how they would fix it, the answers that came back were not slogans. They were work orders. The best of them are woven in below, credited the way their authors asked: by role, never by name, because caution about your own job is not cowardice. It is arithmetic.
The list belongs to Bibb County alone, because it is built from Bibb’s own records. Other districts have the same diseases and are welcome to every word. But the names, the numbers, and the work orders here are Bibb’s.
Teachers and readers sent more ideas than this list can hold, and not every idea survived checking. One submission urged zero-basing the entire district: start every budget and every job over from nothing, with everyone re-interviewing for their own job. The audit behind that instinct is sound, and it leads this list. The purge is not. In Houston, Texas, in 2023, every teacher at 28 schools was forced to reapply for the job she already held, and nearly half were gone by fall. This list keeps what the evidence supports and drops what it does not. What follows is not every repair anyone proposed. It is the seventeen that held up.
The Short Version
- Audit the district, then make every office justify its budget from zero, a fifth of the district at a time, the way one retired Bibb administrator who wrote in urged.
- Shrink the central office to peer-district staffing, cap the rented-lawyer habit at what Houston County pays, and decide the half-empty schools question instead of studying it for a third year. Together those items are worth roughly $6 million a year on the series’ own documented figures.
- Put every administrator back in a classroom for real substitute days every year, make every administrator answer annually to the staff who work under them, give teachers their planning periods and their first morning back, and back them on discipline from the superintendent’s office down.
- Publish the numbers the district already holds and refuses to release: school-by-school teacher retention, the substitute fill rate, and the exit survey results.
Table of Contents
The Repair List, in Short
For the skimmers: every repair in this article, in order. The evidence, the arithmetic, and the teachers who sent these in follow.
- Ban the word non-negotiable. Strike it from every district email, meeting, and memo, and replace it with the reason, stated out loud, that a teacher is allowed to argue with. A district that forbids negotiation forbids the suggestions that would fix it, so this repair comes first: nothing else on this list can happen in a building where no one may talk back.
- Audit it, then zero-base it. Commission a real audit of the whole district, then make every department justify its budget from zero, a fifth of the district each year, instead of inheriting last year’s spending.
- Make the board do board work. Read contracts before signing them, ask the rude question on the record, run real searches for senior jobs, show the hiring receipts, and publish the paperwork, including the secret settlements and the organizational chart. Require educational leadership and financial competence in every superintendent search, with a finance chief empowered to challenge recommendations.
- Shrink the chart to peer size. Bibb runs about 26 district administrators per 10,000 students against a peer median of about 16; matching the peers removes roughly 21 positions and saves about $3.3 million a year. Publish what the instructional coaches cost and what they are certified to teach, then end the coaching job as Bibb runs it. The only version worth keeping is mentoring new teachers, and Repair 17 builds that instead. Close the downtown offices and base the staff inside the schools. All hands on deck.
- Put every administrator back in a classroom. The superintendent and every certified central office administrator substitute teach eight to ten days a year against real vacancies, and every principal teaches inside his own building, because the people who write policy should stand where it lands.
- Fix the boss problem. Evaluate every administrator annually and anonymously by the staff who work under them, publish the results and the exit interviews, count both in contract renewals, fire the administrators the staff rates toxic year after year, and never promote anyone to principal without a record of keeping teachers. End the complaint trap, in which a complaint sent downtown through Let’s Talk is forwarded to the principal it names, who then screams at the staff about it. End the doctor’s note after a single sick day and the permission form for a dentist appointment. And take the boldest step on this list: fire Superintendent Dan Sims and hire Jared Lamb, the Baton Rouge principal who runs his school from a rolling cart, because he is the opposite of every administrator Bibb teachers have endured.
- Follow the money rules. Cap the district credit cards hard and publish every statement, pre-approve travel above a set amount at the board, bring the outside legal bills down toward what Houston County pays, and judge every contract against a published savings schedule, starting with the $8.29 million overhead assignment Part 2 already built. Apply the purchase test to every major purchase, publish every contract, open the bidding, and reconcile the district’s own conflicting figures, as Part 1 asked.
- Decide the school buildings question. Stop studying consolidation and decide it in the open: more than 2,600 elementary seats stand empty and each honest consolidation saves roughly a million dollars a year. And sell the downtown administration tower instead of spending $10 million renovating it.
- Give teachers their time back. Protect the planning period and replace the A/B hybrid with a true block schedule. Cap faculty meetings at fifteen minutes, replace the email blizzard with one staff page, and end the survey detention. Kill the focus-board mandate, the scripted district lesson plans, the daily learning target, the weekly professional learning session, and the word non-negotiable, and exempt veteran teachers from lesson plans. Guarantee a duty free lunch. Let teachers wear jeans. Cancel the Coliseum convocation, give back the first morning, let teachers go home on planning days when the work is done, and end the intercom interruptions.
- Pay people like you want them to stay. Protect and fund the salary steps so experience pays. Bibb’s ladder falls $11,841.46 behind Houston County’s at its top rung, which means the district fines its most loyal teachers the most for staying. Cap class sizes where small classes matter most: the early grades, and classes built around children with disabilities.
- Fix the substitute problem in the open. Publish, every year and by school, the numbers the district already holds and refuses to release: teacher retention, the substitute fill rate under the Kelly contract, and the exit survey results.
- Back teachers on discipline, from the top. Back administrators publicly, from the superintendent and the board down, with real alternative placements for persistently disruptive students and no student sent back to class with a lollipop. End the whole-class bathroom march with a digital hall pass system, and build a coverage system so a teacher can step out for two minutes.
- Make grades mean something again. End Bibb’s 40/40/20 grading formula, which weights daily work the same as every unit test combined, so a high school student can average 50 on every test and still pass. Put tests, projects, and the final at 85 percent or better, cap daily work at 15 percent, the ceiling Fulton County already uses, fix middle school first, and publish the weights. End grade floors and audit credit recovery. The full case is in the standalone report, “40/40/20: The Formula That Lets Bibb Students Fail Every Test and Pass.”
- Build the trades back up. Put trade pathways in the comprehensive high schools, add twelve minutes of advisement telling every senior that CLEP tests exist and that a passing score is free college credit, and begin the looking in eighth grade with rotations through hands-on careers.
- Make technology serve the classroom. Set a published deadline for fixing teacher technology tickets, vet new tools on evidence, stop paying duplicative dues, hire technology leaders who have held the job before, and hold the technology chief to a measurable standard. In the elementary grades, give children back the hands-on work the screens replaced, and pay teachers to prep it.
- Feed them a lunch worth eating. Every Bibb student already eats free; the open fight is what the central kitchen trucks in. Put the cooking back in the buildings, serve real food, and give children time to eat it.
- Give every new teacher a mentor. Pair each first and second year teacher with a trained mentor in the same subject, pay the mentor a stipend, share a planning period, and lighten the new teacher’s first year load. New teachers quit at the highest rates in the profession. This repair aims at the leak where it is largest. (The in-building support team moved into Repair 12, where the referral machinery lives.)
The Opposite of All This
There is a working principal in this country who shows what the opposite looks like. Jared Lamb heads a school in Baton Rouge. He gave up his office and runs the place from a rolling cart, out in the halls, where the work is. Hundreds of thousands of educators follow him, and the reason is simple: he treats teachers as the solution instead of the suspect population. Here he is, in one minute, listing ten things schools should eliminate:
Watch what he actually does, because the program is not complicated. He spends the first hour of his day walking his school, checking in with every teacher, asking one question: how are you, and what do you need? The cart is stocked like a workbench (tissues, Band-Aids, pencils, door stops) because the problems he solves on those rounds are practical: a broken copier, a missing supply, a teacher who needs two minutes to breathe. His meetings run five or ten minutes, because the relationship is already built and nobody needs a conference room to say what a hallway conversation settles. His professional development days protect big blocks of teacher work time. Supporting teachers, in his telling, is the real work of a school leader. The paperwork is what you do after. Hold that against the Bibb way, administrators behind office doors and directives flowing downhill from people who have not taught the classes they are directing, and the contrast is the whole argument.
So here is the boldest repair on this list, and it is not a formula or a budget line. Fire Superintendent Dan Sims and hire Jared Lamb. I mean it plainly. In eleven years in Bibb County, the administrators I dealt with hid in offices, managed by ambush, and treated teachers as a problem to be monitored. Lamb is the opposite of every one of them: visible instead of hidden, serving his staff instead of surveilling them, and answering for his building in public, in his own voice, instead of through a communications office. A board cannot manufacture a leader like that out of a search firm and a slide deck. But it can go hire one.
And the case for firing Sims is not temper. It is the record, and this series spent five parts assembling it. The one number his administration advertises is the graduation rate, 89 percent, and Part 3 put it next to the number it never advertises: 23 percent proficiency. A diploma count that climbs while the learning it certifies does not is not an achievement. It is the mirage, and presiding over it is the whole of the claimed record. Look for the concrete improvement, the thing a parent or a teacher can point to that works better in a Bibb classroom because Dan Sims runs the district, and the record this series built comes back empty. Three straight adopted budgets planning to spend more than the district takes in. A state moderate-risk classification with four audit findings. A senior team that grew while enrollment fell, hired largely without searches. The money followed to vendors and consultants in Part 2, the paperwork withheld in Part 4, the classrooms in Part 5 where teachers describe mandates piling up and support that never arrives. What the district does produce, relentlessly, is presentation: the staged videos, the photo opportunities, the self-congratulation. A parent posting publicly about her child’s case last May named him a “social media” superintendent, and the nickname has stuck because it fits the observable record. Teachers in this article’s own submissions said it in their own way: skip the photo ops. Firing a superintendent is a serious act, and this list does not ask for it over style. It asks because after four years the evidence of improved teaching and learning is the one exhibit the administration has never produced, and under Repair 6’s own scorecard, published results counted in renewal, that absence is the finding.
Fixing Bibb County
1. Ban the Word Non-Negotiable
The first repair on this list costs nothing, takes one board vote, and comes first because everything else depends on it. Ban the word non-negotiable from every district email, meeting, and memo.
The word is not a policy. It is a door closing. When an administrator calls a mandate non-negotiable, the sentence underneath it is this: you have no say, your professional judgment is not part of this, and the conversation is over before it starts. A district that talks that way has announced, in one word, that it does not want to hear the people who do the work. And then it wonders why nothing improves. Improvement is a suggestion before it is anything else. Somebody in a classroom notices that a mandate wastes an hour, that a program does not work, that a form duplicates another form, and says so. If the culture has already ruled that saying so is insubordination, the suggestion dies where it was born, and the district keeps the failure and loses the teacher.
So the repair is not etiquette. Every directive that arrives in a Bibb classroom arrives with its reason attached, in plain language, and a named person a teacher can argue with. Negotiation runs both ways: a teacher’s idea for doing the job better gets a hearing and an answer, not a label that ends the conversation before it starts. Almost everything in a school is negotiable. The exceptions are law, safety, and the rights of the children: the duties in a child’s disability plan, mandated reporting, test security. Those are not the district’s to bargain away, and nobody is asking it to. Everything else is a choice somebody made, and a choice that cannot survive being questioned out loud should not survive at all.
A leader who has a reason gives the reason. Non-negotiable is what you say when the reason would not survive being said out loud. Strike the word, and every other repair on this list gets the one thing it cannot work without: a district where telling the truth upward is a job duty instead of a career risk.
2. Audit It, Then Zero-Base It
The most sweeping repair sent in came from a retired special education teacher and administrator, and it follows only the ban above: do a full audit of the district, then make its budget justify itself from zero. Not the ceremonial audit that produces a binder and a press release. The kind where every department starts the budget year at zero and argues for each dollar as if it were new. After three consecutive adopted budgets with planned operating gaps of roughly $9.35 million, $20.77 million, and $15 million, the argument that last year’s spending justifies this year’s has expired. The state has already classified Bibb as a moderate-risk district after four audit findings, each one attributed by the district’s own documents to management oversight. A district under a corrective-action plan does not get to call a real audit an insult. It gets to call it the assignment. The audit this list means is a performance and efficiency audit, commissioned by the board from outside the district, with every finding published alongside a deadline and the name of the official responsible for answering it.
The same reader went further: have everyone re-interview for their jobs. That part of her advice did not survive checking, and this article will not pretend otherwise. In Houston, Texas, in 2023, the state-appointed superintendent made every teacher at 28 schools reapply for the job she already held. Nearly half did not come back that fall, and Houston’s teacher turnover hit 32.2 percent in 2024-25 against 18.8 percent statewide. A mass re-interview is a purge wearing an audit’s clothes, and Bibb, which already loses one teacher in six in a normal year, cannot afford one. What survives is narrower, and aimed where Part 4 pointed: a senior leadership team that grew from 13 to 14 while enrollment fell, with new top layers created in a single 2024 reorganization and filled without a reported search. So post those jobs. Every senior appointment made without a competitive search since 2022 gets competed openly at its next vacancy or contract renewal, and the people holding them are welcome to win them back in the open. Zero-basing itself gets done the way districts that actually use it do it: a fifth of the budget at a time, every office justifying its spending from zero once in five years, with the paperwork carried by the office that owns the budget, not dumped on schools.
3. Make the Board Do Board Work
Every failure in this series passed under a board’s eyes at some point, which is why the cheapest repairs on this list are habits, not purchases. Read the contract before you sign it. Ask the rude question on the record, while it can still change the vote. A powerful, highly paid executive job supervising other people’s money needs boards that read contracts and ask rude questions, a lesson my comparison of Georgia’s schools with Sweden’s drew years ago. Bibb County’s board, in the Dallemand years, largely did neither, and the invoice for that politeness came to about $54 million.
Run real searches for senior jobs and publish the fact that you did. Part 4 asked for any record of a search, finalist list, or interview process for the senior appointments since 2022, and the record it could find was close to empty. Then publish the paperwork: the purchasing card statements, the travel records, and the full efficiency report the district paid $58,050 for. Every item on Part 4’s records list already exists, already belongs to the public, and is being withheld by choice. A board that publishes its own receipts does not need a watchdog. This series exists because Bibb’s board prefers the other arrangement. And end secret settlements: settlements already signed keep their terms, but no settlement the board approves from now on hides its amount from the people paying it.
One more governance repair from the same reader’s list: pair former principals with records of success alongside new principals as mentors, especially in the district’s struggling schools. A new principal in a hard building currently gets a supervisor carrying a spreadsheet. Give her a predecessor who has actually run a building like hers, with a direct line to the superintendent and the board and a deadline for a written answer when she says the schedule is wrong. Advice with a guaranteed hearing, not a second boss: the sitting principal keeps the authority, and keeps the accountability in Repair 6.
Three demands from the earlier parts belong here. Require educational leadership and financial competence in the same superintendent search, and seat a finance chief and purchasing staff with standing to challenge a recommendation before it is bought (Part 2). For every senior hire, show the receipts: the posting, the pool, the interviews (Part 4). And post the organizational chart on the district’s website, where the public can find it, instead of in the audited financial report, where it is least likely to look (Part 4).
4. Shrink the Chart to Peer Size
Part 4 did the arithmetic and it has not been answered: Bibb runs about 26.2 district administrators per 10,000 students against a median of 16.3 across six comparable Georgia districts. Staff the central office the way the peers do and roughly 21 administrator positions disappear, at a saving of about $3.3 million a year. The count uses the same job categories in every district compared, so the comparison is apples to apples. The district’s own consultants at LEAN Frog, in the efficiency study the board bought and then largely shelved, sketched the same direction from inside the building. They found departments running on manual labor and paper timesheets, and a cost of $104 to process a purchase order that benchmark districts process for $63, and they wrote that a pending assistant superintendent retirement created a window in which the six-figure line might not need to be refilled. The board took eight months to fill the seat instead. Board member Sundra Woodford has said on the record that the board asked for an efficiency study of the central office itself and never got one; the LEAN Frog operations review is not that study. Order it. Publish it. Then follow it, starting with the rule the consultants implied: when a senior administrator leaves, the default is that the job is redesigned or gone, not refilled by reflex.
A retired teacher who wrote in would go further than shrinking the chart. Close the downtown offices, she said, and base most of the people in them inside the schools, where an extra adult is hall presence, classroom help, and a second set of hands instead of a calendar invitation. Sensitive functions, human resources, payroll, and anything involving a personnel file, stay in a district office on Riverside Drive, where a family’s private business is not conducted in a school hallway. The district’s most expensive employees are concentrated in the one building in the county with no children in it. Her motto for the repair was four words long: all hands on deck.
One count from Part 2 has still never been published: how many instructional coaches and curriculum staff the district employs, and what they cost in total. Publish both numbers, and alongside them what those same people could build in-house. A chart cannot be shrunk honestly until every chair on it is counted, including the ones with coach on the door. My own position goes past counting them: eliminate the job as Bibb runs it. I taught under an academic coach at Rutland. She had been an elementary school teacher, she had never taught in a high school, and the professional learning she ran for us, every week, was useless. What the coaches do in Bibb, in my experience, is not coaching at all. They check whether teachers turned in the lesson plans, they carry the principal’s clipboard into classrooms, and they report back on who is complying. That is a monitor with a salary, and it is the opposite of help. So publish the whole file first: how many coaches there are, what they cost in total, what fund pays them, and what each one is actually certified and experienced to teach. The district is welcome to answer from its own roster. Then end the job in that form, and spend the money on people who face children. The one version of coaching worth a dollar is the version Bibb does not run: a teacher certified and experienced at the level she serves, working only with new teachers, in their classrooms, with no reporting line to the principal and no check boxes. That version survives, and it is Repair 17.
5. Put Every Administrator Back in a Classroom
This proposal ran in Part 4, and the principle stays unsoftened: a policy lands in a classroom, and the people who write it should have to stand where it lands. The number gets set by the one district that actually does it. El Paso, Texas requires every salaried central office employee, about 255 people including the superintendent, to substitute teach at least eight days a year, and projects roughly $255,000 a year in substitute savings from the requirement alone. So: the superintendent and every certified central office administrator substitute teach eight to ten days a year, scheduled against real vacancies first and absent teachers second, in the subjects their certification covers. While they cover, they work under the same rules teachers work under: the absent teacher’s plan, the data entry, the board posting, all of it. That is what makes it real instead of a photo opportunity. Principals teach inside their own buildings instead: covering a class so a teacher can watch a colleague teach, or taking a section when a room would otherwise sit empty, in blocks the building can spare, because a principal pulled out of his own hallway for six weeks is a discipline system with nobody home. Visiting is not teaching. Teaching is your name on the roster and thirty faces watching when the plan falls apart.
6. Fix the Boss Problem
Ask me why I left teaching and I will not start with the pay, the paperwork, or the students. I will start with the bosses. My personal number one reason for walking away was the toxic work environment built by toxic, micromanaging administrators, principals above all: the kind who treat a faculty as a suspect population, manage by gotcha walkthrough and data meetings about numbers nobody believes, and make a school feel like a probation, not a profession. Teachers have a saying for it: people do not quit jobs, they quit their bosses. It is a saying, not a statistic.
The research is not soft. Across two decades of studies, of everything inside a school’s own control, nothing predicts whether a teacher stays or leaves like the quality of the administration. New York City data, built to rule out sour grapes from teachers already out the door, found teachers’ views of their administration had the greatest influence on retention decisions by far. North Carolina’s workforce records say the same, and Gallup gives the folk saying its plainest number: one in two American workers has quit a job at some point to get away from a manager. Teachers say the same in their own words: in the forums where they compare notes, the loudest complaint is not pay but administrators who will not back them on discipline, and a supportive administrator beats every other answer, pay included, when teachers are asked what keeps them from quitting.
Two limits belong on the record. Forced to name one single reason, most departing teachers name retirement, family, or a better job; only a few percent name the administration. A survey checkbox is not a career. And the administrator effect runs strongest on leaving a school or a district, weaker on leaving the profession. Bibb kept 82 percent of its teachers in 2025 while Houston County, under the same state measure, kept 89 percent, and in its worst recent year Bibb kept only 75 percent.
So the repair is not sensitivity training. It is accountability with teeth, aimed at the one layer that currently answers to nobody below it.
First, every principal and central office administrator gets an annual, anonymous evaluation from the staff who work under them, published in aggregate and counted, for real, in contract renewal. In eleven years in Bibb County, nobody ever handed me a survey asking what I thought of my administrators. Evaluations flow downhill only, which is how a toxic administrator survives for years in plain sight of every teacher in his building. The survey has to be anonymous to be honest, and run from outside the district: publish a building’s results only when enough staff answered that nobody can be identified, and keep the raw answers where no administrator can reach them. An administrator whose own staff, protected and anonymous, rates him toxic year after year is not a leadership style. He is a finding. A survey score alone does not fire anyone, and it should not: a principal who enforces an unpopular rule can be rated down by the people it applies to, and an empty chair where a boss should be rates beautifully. So the survey triggers the real instruments: the building’s teacher retention record, its discipline consistency, and a formal review on the full record, the administrator told the findings and given the chance to answer them, the due process any professional is owed. Bottom results repeated across years, on the survey and the retention record together, end renewals. Fire them is the short version, and after watching the good teachers leave and the bad bosses stay, it has earned its place on this list, with the evidence attached.
Second, publish the exit interviews. A district losing roughly one teacher in six to one in four publishes no exit data at all. Make the exit survey anonymous, standard, and public, so the reasons stop being a rumor the district can deny. When I left, after eleven years, there was no exit interview. Nobody asked why. I got a generic, mostly multiple choice survey where what I really thought had no answer to choose.
Third, a discipline-backup guarantee with a paper trail: an administrator who returns a referred student to a classroom documents the consequence given, so support becomes a record instead of a slogan (Repair 12 takes that up in full). Fourth, stop promoting the problem: nobody becomes a principal on the strength of an interview and a slide deck. Require a record of keeping teachers, and treat a building that hemorrhages staff as a leadership failure with a name attached.
And do not tell me the channel already exists. Bibb has Let’s Talk, and here is what it does. A teacher complains about a principal to the superintendent’s office, and the office sends a copy to the principal it names. Then comes the after-school meeting, and the screaming: who is complaining, and why don’t you have the balls to come talk to me. I sat through versions of that meeting more than once in eleven years. A complaint system that delivers the complaint to the person complained about is not a channel. It is a trap. The staff worked that out years ago; the complaints stopped, and downtown mistakes the silence for contentment.
Then build the channel that should replace it: complaints about an administrator go to an outside party the board hires, not up the administrator’s own chain of command. Retaliation for using it is itself a firing offense. The district publishes every year how many complaints arrived, how many were answered, and how long the answers took. The same accountability runs to the top floor: the board evaluates the superintendent annually against a published scorecard: teacher retention, the substitute fill rate, discipline consistency, and whether the adopted budget is the budget the district actually ran. The instrument is public before it is used, and the results are public after.
Trust shows up in the small print too. Part 5 recorded a teacher required to produce a doctor’s note after a single sick day, and a permission form demanded for a dentist appointment. (The note exists to solve a coverage problem, and it solves it badly; Repair 11 is the honest fix.) End both. A district that makes a grown professional prove a sick day and ask permission for the dentist has announced what it thinks of its staff.
What the opposite of all this looks like is near the top of this article, in one minute of video.
7. Follow the Money Rules
Cap the district credit cards hard instead of cancelling them, because this article’s own numbers argue against a purchase order for every pencil: Repair 4 priced one purchase order at $104 to process, against a $63 benchmark. A card with a low limit, an itemized receipt, and a statement the public can read is cheaper and easier to audit. Every card statement gets published monthly, purchase orders remain the rule for major purchases, and an individual card is cancelled the day its holder cannot document a charge. Require board pre-approval for travel above a dollar amount the board sets in public. Bring the outside legal bills down to what Houston County pays: Bibb spent $34.20 per student per year on professional legal services, $2,918,751.38 across fiscal 2022 through 2025, against Houston County’s $2.48, and closing just that gap saves about $677,000 a year, every year, without touching a classroom. The comparison is a question, not a verdict: some of Bibb’s bill is litigation and special education matters no district chooses. So add the mechanism: a published annual legal report separating the routine bills from the lawsuits, and outside counsel hired through open competition on a set cycle, so the rate is a market price instead of a habit.
Then apply Part 2’s standing test to everything else. Publish a savings schedule in which every proposed cut shows its current annual cost, the net saving this year, the recurring saving afterward, the implementation date, the responsible official, and the effect on schools. Part 2 already built the board an $8.29 million savings assignment aimed entirely at overhead, contracts, and discretionary spending, with no school closure and no classroom cut in it. Put the Leader in Me contract, $363,759 for 2026-27 on the district’s own board brief, on notice at its next lawful renewal point and make it produce a credible local evaluation or end. Publish an inventory of every paid software platform: seats licensed, seats actually used, price, purpose, and overlap. Bibb pays $413.98 per student for web subscriptions and licenses against Houston County’s $159.58, and a license nobody uses is not generosity. It is a leak. Winston’s Rule applies to all of it: a contract is not a pet. The district does not have to feed it because it has learned to wait by the bowl.
One accounting rule governs every dollar in this article, so no saving gets counted twice. The chart in Repair 4 is worth about $3.3 million a year; the legal gap above, about $677,000; consolidation, in Repair 8, is priced net and listed separately. Part 2’s $8.29 million assignment is the umbrella these items sit under, not one more item added on top. The tower sale is one time money and appears nowhere in the recurring column: one time proceeds can buy buildings and equipment, and cannot pay a salary. Where a figure here is an estimate, the article says so; where it is the district’s own number, the district is welcome to publish a better one.
Part 2’s other money rules belong here too. Run the purchase test on every major purchase: publish what was bought, what was used, what it accomplished, and what an alternative would have cost. Publish a full contract inventory: scope, term, cost, funding source, renewal provisions, and responsible office. Open the procurement itself: the solicitation, all responsive prices, the criteria, the scores, and who requested, evaluated, and approved the purchase. And Part 1 asked for one smaller thing that has still never happened: a line-by-line reconciliation of the figures in the district’s own reports that do not agree with each other. The board should want it even if nobody downtown does.

8. Decide the School Buildings Question
By the district’s own consultants’ count, 9 of Bibb’s 19 elementary schools hold fewer than 450 students and more than 2,600 seats stand empty. The documented saving runs about $900,000 to $1.14 million a year per consolidated elementary school. That is the gross figure, the avoidable cost of running the building, before the offsets, and honesty requires the offsets. California closed schools for a decade, and a Stanford study of every closure in the state found the savings mostly eaten by lost enrollment and new costs, ending near break even. Bibb’s case differs in the way that matters: these children move to another Bibb school across town, not out of the district, and the figures are the district’s own consultants’. Still, every closure proposal publishes its net number, after transportation, transition costs, and enrollment effects, school by school, before any vote. Two limits get set before the vote as well, not after: a maximum bus ride for a young child, and class sizes in the receiving schools no larger than the caps Repair 10 sets. And one guarantee is written in before any of it is debated: no teacher loses a job to a closure. Staff follow their students to the receiving schools. A district whose problem is teachers quitting does not solve it by laying off the ones who stayed. What the board has done instead is study it: one firm, a decision in April 2025 to close nothing and pursue rezoning, a second firm hired to study the rezoning, and a fresh order in June 2026 to review consolidation again. Two firms, two years, and nothing closed. Consolidation done honestly is defensible, and each proposal should show enrollment, capacity, facility condition, and the effect on families. What is not defensible is the permanent study, which costs money to produce and saves none.
The same discipline applies downtown: before spending $10 million renovating a tower the district owns, publish the case for not selling it instead. Buildings are assets. Sentiment is not a facilities plan. Part 4 put the stronger version on the record, and this list adopts it: sell the tower. Move the administration into the Riverside complex and the vacant space in the schools the taxpayers already own, and let a private owner worry about the mechanical plant. A district short of classroom money is sitting on a downtown asset it does not need.

9. Give Teachers Their Time Back
The shortest submission I received may matter most. A Bibb County second grade teacher sent it, and its first line was five words long: give us our planning period. Stop forcing teachers to produce data that no one reads. Stop making teachers handle all the behaviors. And notice her trap: the only discipline consequence available is taking away a student’s specials, which parks the student with the teacher during the teacher’s planning period, so the punishment lands on the adult. That is not a discipline plan. It is a scheduling error with a moral attached.
She is describing, from a second grade classroom, the machinery Part 5 documented from mine. The planning time on my Rutland schedule was a rumor other people got to act on, and the work that did not fit the day moved to evenings and weekends, unpaid. Set the planning period in something harder than pencil: meetings cannot take it, coverage cannot eat it except in a genuine emergency, and every taking is logged, published by school each term, and counted in the principal’s evaluation under Repair 6. Cap coverage duty, staff substitutes like the district means it, and protect lunch the same way: a duty free lunch is a teacher’s every day, not a favor traded for coverage.
Give teachers back the first morning of the year, which the district spends bussing them to the Macon Coliseum for a convocation none of them can hear. Part 5 told the story of Fayette County, Kentucky, where teachers revolted over the same ritual and the superintendent canceled it and made the day a teacher workday. Count the venue, the buses, the staging, and thousands of paid hours sitting in an arena, every year. Cancel the arena and spend the money where the district claims it is short: another teacher, or the academic resources departments have never once been invited to request.
The same theft runs at both ends of the calendar. The planning days before the students arrive and after they leave come with nothing left to plan: the room is decorated, or stripped and the grades are in, and the staff sits anyway until the hour it is permitted to leave, because presence is the point. When there is nothing to do, say so and let them go home.
Bibb built the next problem into the schedule itself. The high schools run a modified block schedule, an A/B rotation in which students carry eight classes at once: on A days the first four periods, on B days the fifth through the eighth. A teacher’s planning period rides that rotation, so it exists only every other day. In an A-B-A-B-A week I planned on three days. The next week, B-A-B-A-B, I planned on two. On the days in between I taught straight through, bell to bell, with a 25-minute lunch as the only break. No time to plan the next lesson, grade the last one, call a parent, or breathe. It was miserable, and it was miserable by design.
The fix is not complicated. Scrap the hybrid and run a true block schedule: four classes a semester, so a student carries four courses at a time instead of eight, and a teacher teaches three of the four blocks and plans during the fourth, every single day. The trade deserves naming: a course finished in December sits untouched before a May exam, and sequential subjects like languages and band can gap a semester. Sequence related courses back to back to blunt both. Georgia districts already run true blocks, Cobb and Whitfield and Dalton among them, and the state’s testing calendar already includes December end of course exams built for semester courses. And the demand underneath holds either way: one protected planning period, every day, however the board builds the day.
The same schedule carries a second piece of arithmetic. Bibb’s department heads get two planning periods. The chair teaches one less class, and the chair’s students do not evaporate: they are shuffled onto the teachers who are not department heads, who take the larger classes. In a department of three, the other two teachers absorb the displaced students. The chair’s lighter load is not a gift from the district; it is purchased with the heavier loads of the colleagues down the hall. Release time for real chair work is legitimate, but it has to be staffed, not stolen: where a department is too small to absorb the loss of a section, the district funds an additional staffing line. The general rule belongs beside it: set a roster ceiling for every classroom, and state in advance what happens when it is crossed, a co-teacher, a split class, or paid overload, decided before August, not absorbed in silence in October.
Cut the paperwork to one entry. My article on why teachers are quitting named the fix years ago: the same information typed into several systems that do not talk to each other is a tax paid in evenings, so any new form must kill an old one. Part 5 put my testimony on the record: too much of that data is meaningless because the environment makes accurate collection nearly impossible. A district that wants honest data should ask for less of it, once, in one place, and then read it. And cap the testing calendar itself: every district test a child sits for gets named on one published calendar with the hours it eats, and a new test joins only when an old one leaves.
Let the people who teach choose what they teach from. Curriculum and texts should be adopted by committees that include the classroom teachers who will stand in front of them, as the retired administrator’s list put it, not delivered as a finished decision from an office that will never open the book. Committee work is work: it carries a stipend or release time, or it is one more unpaid meeting with a nicer name. And instruction about teaching should come only from people qualified to give it: a current teacher put the rule plainly, if a district leader is not certified in the grade level or subject area, that leader should not be issuing directives about how to teach it. Scoped honestly, the rule governs curriculum and teaching method, not the whole job: a principal still runs her building. But no mandate about how to teach a subject lands until a teacher certified in that subject has reviewed it. Her example was elementary teachers elevated into executive roles, then directing high school instruction they had never taught. Her closing instruction to the central office was three words long, and this list adopts it as policy: listen, listen, listen.
A current Bibb teacher said the whole complaint in one breath, and it stands exactly as written:
“Give teachers time to plan. Stop mandates such as posting a focus boards that takes up an entire side of a whiteboard. Stop requiring teachers to sit through meetings to discuss what they need to do but never give them time to do it. Allow teachers to be creative and not mandate them to teach from a script, such as the district lesson plans. Trust teachers to do what’s best for their students instead of micromanaging them. Cut the length of the lesson plans. Make them as simple as the teacher does. This the student will do this. The testing is insane, the data is even crazier. We test and look at data so much, but never have time to do anything with it.”
Read that list again and notice what most of it costs: nothing. The planning time at its head costs coverage, and Repair 11 prices the substitutes honestly. The rest is permission the district is withholding: to plan, to think, to teach like a professional instead of reciting a script somebody downtown wrote.
Take the lesson plan off the tribute list, with one exception. A brand-new teacher in a first year can fairly be asked to show a plan; it is a scaffold, and reading it is coaching. Every teacher, veteran included, keeps an emergency substitute plan on file, because the coverage in Repair 5 depends on it, and a teacher on an improvement plan still submits, because the submission is the point of that plan. A veteran should never have to submit one, ever. A teacher with twenty years in a classroom does not teach one inch better because an administrator initialed a template on a Sunday night. Bibb keeps the practice because paperwork is auditable and teaching, inconveniently, is not. And the mandate has nothing behind it: no credible research shows that making a veteran teacher submit plans improves her teaching or her students’ results, and the district has never cited any. Keep the plan as a tool she makes for her own use. End it as a tax she pays to be left alone.
While the eraser is out, take the daily target off the board, and the standard beside it. Every morning the teacher writes the target up for a visitor who may never come and copies the standard out so a walkthrough can check the box. The students have never read it. Objectives belong in the teacher’s planning, where they shape the lesson. Chalked on the board as liturgy, they shape nothing but the observation rubric and cost the first minutes of every class. And change the walkthrough form that checks for the posting, or the posting returns within a month wearing a new name. The rubric is the engine; the inscription is just its exhaust.
Then the faculty meetings, the monthly after-school kind, past contract hours, unpaid. Ours were an interminable nightmare: the principal talking forever about nothing, icebreakers no adult should be subjected to, and the whiteboard ritual, sticky notes written, posted, solemnly admired, and never read by anyone, ever. No meeting runs longer than the business requires, and most months that is ten or fifteen minutes. Everything else goes on the staff page.
And then there is the inbox. Teachers in Bibb work under a daily blizzard of email, announcements stacked on reminders stacked on surveys, all arriving while you are standing in front of thirty students and cannot touch a keyboard. So the survey sits, and three days later the principal announces that nobody is leaving until it is filled out. This is a solved problem: one staff page holding the announcements, the links, and the required actions with their deadlines, plus one short digest a day pointing at it. Bibb is a Microsoft district, and the toolbox it already pays for has every piece of it. The district owns the solution and reaches for the worst tool in the box because nobody was ever taught the better ones. So give one real training, inside contract hours, add the rule that no required action lives anywhere except the page, and enforce it. And end the detention: a board shows who is done and who is not without keeping a single adult after school like a child being punished. Email goes back to being mail, from a person to a person, and everything else lives in one place a teacher can find in the ninety seconds between classes.
And the word that ends every argument before it starts is already gone: Repair 1 struck non-negotiable from the district’s vocabulary, so what lands in a teacher’s inbox from here on is a decision with its reason attached, not a label.
Let teachers dress like the adults they are. In Bibb, jeans are treated as a controlled substance, a privilege doled out on special days and sometimes literally sold, teachers paying for the right to wear denim, as if professionalism lived in the fabric. No lesson ever failed because of a pair of pants. Adopt a dress code that treats staff as professionals, jeans included, every day, free of charge.
The weekly professional learning session goes on the same pile. Professional development, as practiced, is the faculty meeting in a costume: a new initiative, a framework, a bundle of strategies nobody requested, delivered to veterans who could be grading or planning. Real learning happens in departments and in the honest postmortem of a lesson that failed. So the hour does not vanish; it changes owners. It becomes protected department time, teachers of the same subject in a room together, plus peer observation. The training the law actually requires, safety, reporting, and the rest, gets listed honestly, batched, and delivered inside contract hours, not sprinkled across forty afternoons. Everything else the district invents for that hour is eliminated.
And protect the class from the intercom. At Rutland the loudspeaker treated every classroom as its waiting room: announcements all day, and when a list had to be read, it was read, all of it, 50 names, sometimes 100, by a reader who could not pronounce half of them, while instruction stopped and waited. Put the name lists on the daily bulletin where they belong. Keep the intercom for the urgent and the rare.
10. Pay People Like You Want Them to Stay
The retired administrator who proposed the audit also proposed reevaluating administrative pay and restructuring teacher pay, and the series’ numbers say she aimed at the right target. Part 2 and Part 4 both followed Bibb’s pay ladder and found the same shape: it falls further behind Houston County with every year of service, ending $11,841.46 short at its top rung, which is a polite way of saying the district pays its most experienced teachers the largest penalty for staying. My retention article named the national version of the disease: midcareer compression, where veterans barely outearn newcomers and recruitment bonuses insult the people already in the building. Protect the steps, fund them in the adopted budget rather than restoring them in July after the headlines, and rebuild the ladder so that year fifteen pays visibly more than year five. Her other half, reevaluating administrative pay, is not dropped; it is handled where it belongs, in Repairs 3 and 6, the chart and the money rules.
Price the rebuild honestly, because this list does not spend phantom money. The recurring savings documented here are the chart in Repair 4, about $3.3 million a year, and the legal gap in Repair 7, about $677,000, with consolidation counted only at its published net. If that falls short of the full rebuild, the rebuild starts where the bleeding is worst, the shortage subjects in the district’s own figures below: science, special education, and math, with targeted stipends for subjects Bibb cannot staff at any posted salary. The paraprofessionals who carry the inclusion classrooms and the behavior load get a published pay floor alongside the teacher steps: the district’s own salary schedule starts a classroom paraprofessional at $17.59 an hour, and a repair that lifts only the certified staff leaves the building’s other adults near the bottom of the pay building they hold up.
One more purchase belongs in this repair, because Georgia’s teachers named it themselves. In the PAGE survey of 3,408 Georgia educators, the top three retention answers were higher salaries, smaller classes, and protected planning time. So: hard caps on class size in kindergarten through third grade, and in inclusion classes where many children carry disability plans, an IEP or a 504 plan, the legal documents that spell out what a child is owed. Bibb’s own paperwork makes the case without any help. Georgia’s standard caps are 18 children in kindergarten and 21 in grades 1 to 3. Bibb runs on a state waiver, renewed year to year, that lets it set its own maximums, and the maximums Bibb chose are 28 in kindergarten and 28 in grades 1 to 3, a third again as many five year olds in a room as the state standard allows. The repair is modest enough to say in one sentence: in the early grades, meet the state’s own numbers instead of the waiver’s. The strongest class size research in the country, Tennessee’s STAR experiment, found the gains concentrated exactly there, in the early grades, and largest for poor children and Black children, which is to say for Bibb’s children. District wide caps are not promised, because the ledger cannot carry them, and this article does not print checks it cannot cash.
Georgia’s retention data, on the state’s own Educator Pipeline dashboard, puts Bibb’s teacher retention at 75 to 83 percent across 2021 to 2025 while the statewide rate never fell below 89. In 2025 the subject figures were worse where it hurts most: science at 67.92 percent, special education at 68.96, math at 72.41. The district’s own commissioned study put separation at 16.8 percent for 2024-25, above regional and national benchmarks. (Retention and separation are different measures from different sources, which is why both numbers appear; each is labeled with its source.) One teacher in six, gone every year. You do not fix that with a poster in the break room. You fix it with a ladder that rewards the decision to stay.
11. Fix the Substitute Problem in the Open
Part 5 closed with three demands, small and answerable, and they belong in this list because publishing records is a repair a district can perform in a week. Publish the teacher retention rate for every school in the district, every year, calculated from personnel records the district already holds. Separate the voluntary departures from the involuntary ones, so a principal who removes a weak teacher is not scored as a retention failure, and use three year rolling figures for small schools, where one departure swings the percentage. Georgia publishes no school-level retention rate, so no parent in Bibb County can check the churn in their own child’s building; the central office holds those rosters and does not publish them, and that choice, not any law, is what keeps the number secret. Publish or calculate the substitute fill rate under the Kelly Services contract, which the state’s own payment records show was paid $17.9 million across fiscal 2022 to 2025, so the public can learn how often a Bibb classroom that loses its teacher actually gets one. In some Rutland math rooms, by the students’ own public accounts, the answer in some years was no teacher at all. And publish the exit survey results, from responses the district already collects, in a form a departing teacher might recognize as worth answering. While those numbers are being published, run Part 2’s comparison honestly: a fully costed district-managed substitute pool against the agency’s rates and fill performance, worker pay protected, and the cheaper reliable option wins. Publish it either way: if the rate is good, the district deserves the credit, and if it is not, the classrooms living it already know.
12. Back Teachers on Discipline, From the Top
The first repair advice I received came from a retired elementary school secretary. Teachers send a student to the office, she wrote, and the student gets sent back to class with a lollipop. Building administrators cannot suspend when suspension is needed, she reported, because suspensions count against the school in the state report. (Georgia’s school climate ratings do run partly on discipline data, which is exactly the incentive she names.) Teachers spend more time on discipline than on teaching. Her fix was aimed over the principal’s head: it has to come from the superintendent and the board. They need to support teachers and building administrators, publicly, in policy, and when a parent complaint lands. The backing includes the inbox: abusive parent communication routes through the office, and the administrator answers it first. She asked for more alternative classrooms and alternative schools, so that a persistently disruptive student has somewhere real to go, and for consequences that exist on paper to exist in the building.
The retired special education administrator’s list ends at the same place: restructure the district behavior plan. Rewrite the behavior plan with teachers at the table, give administrators consequences they are actually permitted to use, staff alternative placements at a scale that matches the need, and measure principals on whether discipline is consistent, not on whether the suspension column is small. One legal fact governs all of it: children with disabilities keep every right their disability plans give them, including in discipline. Alternative placements run through those legal processes, properly staffed, not around them, and removals are counted and reviewed by race and disability every month, in public, so the repair does not become a faster door for the same children. The secretary told the story that should be stapled to the front of the new plan: in 2007 her son lost nearly a quarter of his instruction to one disruptive classmate, a gifted child who could not be still or quiet, whom Howard Middle rotated through all four groups in his grade so no single group lost all its learning to him. That arrangement served neither the child, who deserved an education built for him, nor the hundred classmates who deserved theirs.
Stop making teachers the phone police: Part 3 documented a no-phone policy with no system behind it, teachers left to confiscate devices students carry in twos and threes while instruction bleeds. Georgia’s Distraction-Free Education Act orders the policy and sets the dates: no phones bell to bell in kindergarten through eighth grade from July 2026, and in the high schools from July 2027. The storage system is the district’s own choice, a designated place in the classroom, lockers, or locked pouches, and the cost of pouches or lockers belongs in the board’s arithmetic, not on teachers. Glynn County and DeKalb did not wait for the high school deadline, and Bibb should not either: adopt the full ban for 2026-27, run the consequences from the office. And fix the front end of special education: the retired secretary reported that a preschooler throwing desks can wait most of a school year for a behavioral specialist to observe and test him. A four year old cannot wait a year for help, and neither can his teacher or the other four year olds. Put a deadline on the district’s own clock, weeks rather than seasons: publish the maximum days from a referral to an observation, and staff the specialists to meet it. The two clocks stay separate: a teacher’s request for help starts the building’s support clock the day it is made. The formal special education evaluation runs on its own legal clock, from parental consent, and the first clock must never be used to delay the second.
Every school gets its own working team for struggling children: teachers, counselors, and specialists together, with authority to act on a referral in days rather than semesters. The district publishes the ratios those teams run on, counselors, psychologists, social workers, and behavior specialists, against state and national benchmarks, so the public can see whether the team is staffed or just named. For special education case managers: a caseload cap, and protected time inside the contract day for the case management paperwork, which the research names as the single biggest factor in whether special education teachers stay or go. Early support is not a luxury item from somebody else’s budget. It is the cheapest version of the problem.
Then there is the bathroom. At Rutland we did not send a student to the restroom. We marched the whole class, needed or not, and a march like that burns ten minutes or more of a class period every time. Nothing stopped three teachers from marching three classes into the same hallway at the same moment: 60 or 70 students in one corridor, fighting, jumping, screaming, and disrupting every classroom they passed. That is not a bathroom break. It is a scheduled riot with a hall pass. The first fix costs nothing: passes by individual request, a cap on how many students are out of any room at once, staggered by grade. If the district wants software after that, it passes the same test as every other tool in Repair 15: evidence, a pilot in the buildings with the worst hallway problem, and published terms for what student data it keeps. Digital hall pass systems (SmartPass and Securly Pass are the best known) let a student request a pass and the teacher approve it with a tap, cap how many students are out at once, and keep a record of who went where and for how long. Bibb manages its buses, its lunches, and its payroll with software. It can manage a hallway.
Jared Lamb, a principal in Baton Rouge, has published his standard in four sentences, in his own words: “We back teachers up with consequences. We remove students from classes when they stop learning for others. We call home. We don’t return students to class 5 minutes later with a lollipop.” Every clause is a policy Bibb could adopt on Monday morning. The top of this article proposes hiring the man. If the board will not do that, it could at least copy his homework.
Part 5 stated the coverage problem flatly: there is no system for covering a teacher who needs to step out, not for an emergency but for two minutes of being human. A building run Lamb’s way solves it as a byproduct, because an administrator is always in the hall. Until then, build a named coverage system, a floater or a buddy classroom, so a teacher can step out without marching a class anywhere.
And one plain sentence belongs in the plan itself: no teacher should be hit at work. A teacher who is assaulted gets backed, the report is protected from retaliation, and the count is published by school every year. In the PAGE survey, 8 percent of Georgia educators reported a deliberate assault by a student. A district that will not count it cannot claim to be fixing it.
13. Make Grades Mean Something Again
Part 3’s mirage, 89 percent graduating and 23 percent proficient, is not a fraud. It is an incentive system working exactly as built, and the repair is to rebuild the incentives. Teachers are afraid to fail students because failing one costs weeks of paperwork, meetings, and a conference that can end with an administrator overriding the grade. When honesty is punished and passing is free, rational people pass. So cut the documentation burden for a failing grade to what defending it genuinely needs, back the teacher’s grade publicly when it is challenged, and end the local habits that print A’s for compliance, including grade floors that award credit for work never turned in. Sequence matters: the paperwork cut and the public backing land in the same vote as the formula change, with a stated rule for reassessment and make up work, because pressure blocked in one place moves to another, into easier tests and quiet curves. And no rule changes mid course, ever: a student is graded under the formula in force when the course began.
Start with the formula itself, which is rigged before any teacher touches it. Bibb computes a high school grade out of three buckets, and the district’s own employee handbook prints the recipe: Instructional Tasks, formative quizzes, classwork, observations, and labs, at 40 percent; Assessment Tasks, the district unit assessments and the summative tests and projects, at 40 percent; and the final exam, or the state End of Course test, at 20 percent. The daily work counts exactly as much as every unit test in the course put together. In middle school it is worse: instructional tasks are 60 percent of the grade and assessments 40, with no final exam in the formula at all.
Run the arithmetic the formula invites. A high school student who does every scrap of the daily work and averages a 50, a failing score, on every assessment and the final still finishes at 70 and passes the course. A middle schooler with perfect daily work needs to average only a 25 on assessments to pass, and a 50 on assessments earns an 80, a B. Run it backward and it gets uglier: a student who plainly knows the material, 90 on every test and the final, but turns in no daily work finishes at 54 and fails. A gradebook built this way is not measuring learning. It is measuring compliance, and billing parents as if it were learning.
Other districts run the same arithmetic and get different answers. Houston County never lets daily work near Bibb’s share: 25 percent in sixth grade, falling to 15 by eighth grade, and 15 in its high school syllabi. Fulton County’s board policy caps practice, its name for daily work, at 15 percent for grades six through twelve. Forsyth County weights formative work at 25 percent and summative assessments at 75. So rebalance: demonstrated mastery, tests, projects, and the final at 85 percent or better; daily work down at 15 percent, where the neighbors keep it. The 85 percent means demonstrated work, mostly in class and proctored, because the summer school story below shows what unproctored work now certifies. Daily work keeps being assigned and checked: Fulton caps the weight, not the assignment. Practice is how learning happens; it just stops masquerading as proof of it. Middle school phases down instead of jumping: a sixth grader steps from 60 percent daily work toward 15 across the middle grades, the way Houston’s does, rather than in one August. And the accommodations in a child’s disability plan are enforced on the assessments that now carry the grade, audited like the weights themselves. The full case against the formula has its own article: “40/40/20: The Formula That Lets Bibb Students Fail Every Test and Pass” runs the arithmetic in both directions and names the one Georgia district that copied the model. It also prints the sourcing problem: a district that no longer publishes its own computation, whose regulation page will not load.
Then run the audit Part 3 asked for and nobody has run: an independent review of credit recovery in Bibb County, how many diplomas it touches, and whether the recovered credits represent recovered learning. Washington, D.C. ran that audit on itself in 2018 and found a third of one graduating class had received diplomas with the help of policy violations. Bibb’s taxpayers deserve to know their own number, whatever it is.
The summer version arrived in the mail. A current teacher reported students completing an entire online summer school course with AI doing the work, the whole course finished in less than an hour, the grade an A, while classroom teachers exhaust themselves teaching students who have learned the lesson the system teaches: the classroom version is for suckers. Her fix was a fork: stop offering summer school in that form, or raise its bar to the classroom’s, proctored, paced, and graded like the learning it claims to replace. A credit that can be earned in an hour by a chatbot is not a second chance. It is the mirage with a summer schedule.
Attendance is the twin repair, because you cannot teach a student who is not in the room. Bibb’s chronic absenteeism stood at 28.5 percent in 2025 against 19.5 percent statewide, and at Southwest High School in 2022-23, 67 percent of students were chronically absent while 80 percent of its seniors graduated. (Two different measures, schoolwide absence and one senior class’s graduation, printed together because the district announces the second and buries the first.) A diploma earned in absentia certifies attendance at the ceremony. Part 4 documented it: the superintendent championed a truancy specialist, the board deadlocked 4 to 4 against funding it, the Macon-Bibb County Commission funded it instead with $345,000 over three years, and in August 2025 the district hired Dr. Dominique Johnson as its first truancy intervention specialist, days after Part 4’s July snapshot found the chair still empty. He was still doing the work in Bibb buildings in the fall of 2026. A filled chair is not yet a program: publish the caseload it carries, the support behind it, and what it has produced. The district reports chronic absenteeism down to 22.7 percent for 2025-26, and the Telegraph reported in March 2026 that 40 percent of Bibb seniors were still chronically absent. Print both numbers, every time. Then enforce the attendance policy the district already has, evenly, and report the numbers school by school alongside the graduation rate every time the graduation rate is announced.
Go Deeper: Three Books on Making Grades Mean Something
Repair 13 is the argument in miniature: a grade should measure learning, and nothing else. Three of the most respected names in grading research have been making that case for years, from different directions.

Grading for Equity, by Joe Feldman
The best-known grading reformer in the country argues that a grade should reflect content mastery only, and he aims that argument at traditional habits as much as at formulas like Bibb’s. One caution, printed because this article checks its own sources: Feldman is this list’s source for the accuracy core, a grade that measures mastery and nothing else, not for the no zeros and minimum grade mandates attached to his wider program, which this article opposes. When the Fordham Institute surveyed 958 teachers on RAND’s national panel in 2025, 81 percent called no zeros grading harmful to student engagement. The teachers are right, and nothing in Repair 13 depends on pretending otherwise.

Fair Isn’t Always Equal, by Rick Wormeli
A working teacher’s classic on what happens to a grade when practice, effort, and behavior get averaged into it, and how to grade the learning instead.

On Your Mark, by Thomas R. Guskey
Guskey takes apart the habits that make report cards meaningless, zeroes and blind averaging chief among them, and shows what to build in their place.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
14. Build the Trades Back Up
The retired secretary asked for more trade classes that would actually engage kids who are not interested in college, and Part 3 made the same argument at national scale: the district loves the phrase college and career ready and practices only the first half. Pushing underprepared students toward degrees they will not finish is not opening doors; the state’s own outcomes data show only about a quarter of Georgia graduates completing a degree within five years, and fewer than one in five of those who arrived needing remedial courses. Meanwhile the economy is short hundreds of thousands of electricians, plumbers, welders, carpenters, and HVAC technicians, in jobs that pay well and cannot be outsourced. The repair is to treat the trades as a first choice rather than a consolation prize: offer Hutchings, the district’s own vocational school, with the same energy the flowchart now reserves for college, build trade pathways into the comprehensive high schools, and let a student who knows he wants to wire buildings stop being scheduled as if he had failed to want something better. The choice belongs to the student and his family, never to a counselor’s assignment: it opens at about fifteen, it keeps college eligibility intact, the door back stays unlocked, and the district publishes who chooses each pathway, by school, so a track that quietly sorts children by income gets caught in its own numbers. A plumber with no debt and a waiting list of customers is doing better than a dropout with $40,000 in loans.
A teacher with more than twenty-five years in Bibb classrooms wrote in with the ground-level version of the same repair, blunter about Hutchings than this article has been. The career center is too small for a district this size, and the plan around it wastes the day: a student rides from the home school to Hutchings, takes the class, and after lunch rides back, with the road eating the hours in between. The fix starts the looking earlier and keeps the learning home. Begin vocational rotations in the eighth grade, art and industrial arts among them, short tours through hands-on careers that give a fourteen-year-old an eye on a future before the flowchart hardens. Then expand vocational training into each high school and let it fill the day there, instead of spending the day on buses between campuses. In order, and priced: fix the Hutchings transportation waste and fill the seats Hutchings already has first, inside Georgia’s existing career, technical, and agricultural education structure and its dual enrollment courses, then phase in the school pathways by student demand, with the instructors, equipment, and safety costs printed before the ribbon is cut, not after.
Part 5 proposed one guidance repair so cheap it is nearly free: an advisement lesson, handouts, ten or twelve minutes, telling every senior that CLEP exists, that a qualifying score earns college credit at the colleges that accept it, and where the door is. (Disclosure, because this article prints its conflicts: my own EduLingo store sells CLEP Spanish practice materials. The advice stands on the College Board’s program, not on my catalog.) Every year, seniors who could have tested out of courses they will now pay for walk past that door because nobody spent twelve minutes pointing at it.
15. Make Technology Serve the Classroom
Part 5’s Adams File documented a technology office that was slow to repair what it broke and quick to convert a breakage into a denial, and the repairs are systems, not personalities. Set a published, time-bound standard for answering and resolving teacher technology tickets, so no classroom request sits unresolved for a month while a required platform sits unusable. Run edtech approvals through a transparent, evidence-based vetting process whose denials rest on actual testing of the tool, not on magazine articles or a membership seal that never rated it. End the district’s duplicative 1EdTech dues while Georgia’s statewide membership already covers access, or publish what the district’s own $16,400 bought that the state’s did not. Fill technology leadership posts against published technical qualifications, and hold the technology chief to a measurable cost-and-performance standard for the whole portfolio, as Part 2 required. The day technology starts grading the teachers who call it for help, it has forgotten its job description. The same published clock governs a classroom with no air conditioning in an August heat wave: building failures get a response standard too, not just software ones.
The retired administrator whose repair list runs through this article added a line that sounds like nostalgia and is not: return to paper and pencil, and reduce screen time outside scheduled lab time. After five parts documenting software subscriptions nobody can prove are used, the burden of proof has moved. A screen in a classroom should have to justify itself the way a contract should, by what it accomplishes, and the work paper does better should go back to paper without apology. With the exceptions named, because they are rights and not preferences: assistive technology and every accommodation in a child’s plan stay, and since Georgia’s state tests are taken on computers, scheduled lab time for keyboarding and platform practice stays too, scheduled in fact and not just in this sentence. Paper costs grading time, which is why this repair travels with Repair 9’s protected hours instead of pretending the hours are free.
The same point arrived from the elementary end of the district, where the screen question is the whole school day. The same teacher, more than twenty-five years in Bibb classrooms, wrote that hands-on learning has all but vanished from the elementary grades: no more center time, no manipulatives, no art, no play, no reading groups. In their place, young children sit on the floor in front of a panel or work on iPads, and reading practice runs through a program called Amira, which the schools must log their minutes on. The program, the teacher wrote, “has a hard time understanding” children with speech issues or heavy dialect, and the minutes get logged anyway. That is one teacher’s report, and the repair treats it the way this article treats every claim: test it. Commission an independent check of the program’s accuracy on Bibb’s own children, speech differences and dialect included, publish the results, and if the tool cannot hear the children it is grading, its contract ends at the next renewal. The repair is the rare item in this article that costs money on purpose: pay teachers to stay and prep. The hands-on classroom was built after school by teachers working free, making the folder games, writing tasks, and art projects that went with the book. Teachers leave on time now, and this one does not blame them. The ask is whether the district will pay for the extra work to get the better product, support and training included for teachers who never learned to prep that way. It gets priced into Repair 10’s table like every other spending repair, at the district’s own hourly rates, so the ledger carries it in the open. The district bought the screens because they could be purchased centrally. The alternative comes in only one currency, and it is teacher hours.
A current teacher wrote that the parents and teachers in her building receive far too much AI-generated content from administration: messages nobody reviewed before sending, carrying conflicting directives, typos, errors, and, in her words, so many words. Her instruction deserves to be adopted verbatim as district policy: if you did not take the time to review it, do not send it. Your families and teachers know more than the machine does, so ask them, then support what they tell you. She signed her submission with a parenthetical that needs no improvement from this desk: this advice was written without any AI input. An administration that cannot be bothered to write, or even read, its own messages to parents has outsourced the one part of the job that is supposed to be leadership.
16. Feed Them a Lunch Worth Eating
Bibb has already settled who eats. Every student in the district gets lunch free, under a federal program that lets high poverty districts serve every child at no charge, and that argument is over. What has never been settled is what they are fed, and how long they get to eat it.
This site’s three-part investigation of Georgia school lunches began with a Bibb parent’s photograph: a barely cooked chicken leg and a cup of canned peaches, offered as a school lunch. The parents who answered that post added the rest of the menu from their own children: a small frozen pizza and an apple, a few nachos with meat sauce, a moldy orange, and a senior breakfast of one small waffle and a handful of blueberries. Those are parent reports and one photograph, labeled as what they are, and a barely cooked chicken leg is not a menu preference. It is a food safety event, and it belongs in front of the health inspectors as well as on this list. One commenter wrote that she thought she was reading about the Bibb County jail until she reached the word school.
The first repair costs nothing: time and a place to eat. Children eating in classrooms, on a clock that barely allows chewing, is a bell schedule choice, and it can be unchosen on Monday. Set a protected minimum of seated minutes, with the food in front of them, in a lunchroom where a lunchroom exists.
The second repair is slower, because it is equipment and people, not attitude. Bibb runs a central kitchen: the district’s own staffing documents describe a Central Kitchen packaging operation, with a cook-chill manager and a shipping and dispatch manager, meals produced in one place, packed, and trucked out to the schools every day. Food cooked somewhere else, chilled, shipped, and reheated has a name in every other line of work, and the name is not lunch. But a central kitchen is a model, not a verdict. The variable that matters is scratch cooking, fresh ingredients prepared from scratch instead of reheated product, and it can be tested honestly instead of argued about. Pilot it in a few buildings, with the equipment, refrigeration, and trained staff priced in the open. Publish the cost per tray and what the children actually eat. Expand what works and kill what does not. A decent meal is not a luxury in a school. It is the one part of the day a child can judge without a rubric.
17. Give Every New Teacher a Mentor
The last repair is aimed at the leak where it is largest. Teachers do not mostly quit in year fifteen. They quit in years one and two, in a new building, often with the hardest roster in it, learning the job alone at a kitchen table at midnight. What Bibb offers a first year teacher today, on its own New Teacher Support page, is an induction program whose stated goal is to “get teachers better faster,” built around a commercial coaching manual, plus a summer orientation. No public Bibb document promises her a trained mentor in her own subject, a stipend for that mentor, a shared planning period, a lighter load, or even how long the program lasts. The one guaranteed mentoring structure that touches Bibb is the state alternative certification route, and it covers only the teachers who arrive through it. There is a better instrument, and it is the one form of coaching the evidence actually supports.
Pair every first and second year teacher with a trained mentor who teaches the same subject at the same level, in the same building where possible. Pay the mentor a stipend, because mentoring is work. Give the pair a shared planning period, because advice without time is a poster. Lighten the new teacher’s load in the first year, one fewer section or one fewer duty, because the first year is where the district either keeps a teacher or starts paying to replace her. And wall the mentor off from evaluation completely: nothing a new teacher tells her mentor reaches a principal, ever, or the honesty the whole design depends on dies in the first semester. This is the surviving form of the job Repair 4 ends: a coach whose only assignment is the new teacher, and whose only product is a teacher who stays.
The research is the strongest retention evidence in this article. A major review of the induction studies found that beginning teachers who received real induction, a mentor, common planning time, and a reduced load, stayed at markedly higher rates. A large study that followed new teachers put numbers on it: comprehensive induction cut the odds of a new teacher leaving her first school by roughly 41 to 55 percent. Georgia’s own teacher association, PAGE, advocates mentor stipends for exactly this. Set it against the cost of the alternative, tens of thousands of dollars for every teacher who walks and must be replaced, and induction is not a kindness. It is the cheapest retention money on this list.
I will end the way Part 5 ended, with demands small enough to be cornered by. Publish the retention rate for every school. Publish the substitute fill rate. Publish the exit surveys. Follow the consultants you already paid for. Answer the savings assignment already on the table. Five parts documented a district that spends its money on the chart, its mornings on ceremony, and its teachers’ evenings on data nobody reads, while the classrooms at the bottom of every one of those decisions do the actual work. The money was there. The teachers were there. The repair is to spend the first on the second, in public, starting now.
References
Every source below was fetched and checked against the claim it supports before this article was written. Anything that failed that check was removed from the evidence base and is not cited here.
- Steiner, E. D., Levine, P. R., Doan, S., & Woo, A. (2025). Teacher Well-Being, Pay, and Intentions to Leave in 2025: Findings from the State of the American Teacher Survey (RRA1108-16). RAND Corporation.
- Pew Research Center (2024). What's It Like To Be a Teacher in America Today? (survey of 2,531 U.S. public K–12 teachers, October 17–November 14, 2023). Pew Research Center, April 4, 2024.
- Tan, T., Wei, W., Carver-Thomas, D., & García, E. (2026). Teacher Turnover in the United States: Who Moves, Who Leaves, and Why. Learning Policy Institute, March 2026.
- Boyd, D., Grossman, P., Ing, M., Lankford, H., Loeb, S., & Wyckoff, J. (2011). "The Influence of School Administrators on Teacher Retention Decisions." American Educational Research Journal, 48(2), 303–333.
- Ladd, H. F. (2011). "Teachers' Perceptions of Their Working Conditions: How Predictive of Planned and Actual Teacher Movement?" Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 33(2), 235–261.
- Carver-Thomas, D., & Darling-Hammond, L. (2017). Teacher Turnover: Why It Matters and What We Can Do About It. Learning Policy Institute.
- Grissom, J. A. (2011). "Can Good Principals Keep Teachers in Disadvantaged Schools? Linking Principal Effectiveness to Teacher Satisfaction and Turnover in Hard-to-Staff Environments." Teachers College Record, 113(11), 2552–2585.
- Grissom, J. A., & Bartanen, B. (2019). "Strategic Retention: Principal Effectiveness and Teacher Turnover in Multiple-Measure Teacher Evaluation Systems." American Educational Research Journal, 56(2), 514–555.
- Grissom, J. A., Egalite, A. J., & Lindsay, C. A. (2021). How Principals Affect Students and Schools: A Systematic Synthesis of Two Decades of Research. The Wallace Foundation.
- Beck, R., & Harter, J. (2015). "Managers Account for 70% of Variance in Employee Engagement." Gallup Business Journal, April 21, 2015 (reporting Gallup's State of the American Manager).
- Gallup (2015). State of the American Manager: Analytics and Advice for Leaders; summarized in Harter, J., & Adkins, A., "Employees Want a Lot More From Their Managers," Gallup, April 8, 2015.
- Kraft, M. A., Marinell, W. H., & Yee, D. S.-W. (2016). "School Organizational Contexts, Teacher Turnover, and Student Achievement: Students in Poverty Bear the Greatest Burden." American Educational Research Journal, 53(5), 1411–1449.
- Kraft, M. A., & Papay, J. P. (2014). "Can Professional Environments in Schools Promote Teacher Development? Explaining Heterogeneity in Returns to Teaching Experience." Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 36(4), 476–500.
- Blase, J., Blase, J., & Du, F. (2008). "The Mistreated Teacher: A National Study." Journal of Educational Administration, 46(3), 263–301.
- Nguyen, T. D., Pham, L. D., Crouch, M., & Springer, M. G. (2020). "The Correlates of Teacher Turnover: An Updated and Expanded Meta-Analysis of the Literature." Educational Research Review, 31, 100355.
- Professional Association of Georgia Educators (2024). Educator survey report (May 2024; 3,698 educators from 169 districts). PAGE.
- Office of the Governor, Georgia (2023–2024), and contemporaneous Georgia reporting (Capitol Beat; WUGA; Valdosta CEO).
- Bibb County and Houston County FY2027 salary schedules, as published in Part 5 of this series.
- Bibb County School District. Employee Handbook, 2023-2024: Computation of Grades (Instructional Tasks 40 percent, Assessment Tasks 40 percent, Final Exam or EOC 20 percent, grades 9-12; 60/40 in grades 6-8).
- Houston County Board of Education. Bonaire Middle School Student Handbook: Grading Weights (Major 40, Minor 30, Daily 25/20/15, Final 5/10/15/20).
- Fulton County Schools. Policy IHA, Grading and Reporting System (Practice capped at 15 percent, grades 6-12).
- Forsyth County Schools. High School Report Cards Overview: Assessment Categories and Grading Weights (Formative 25 percent, Summative 75 percent).
- Houston County Schools. Middle school handbooks (Bonaire Middle School, Warner Robins Middle School, Huntington Middle School, 2026-27) and Veterans High School course syllabus, Food and Nutrition: grading category weights (daily work 25 percent in sixth grade, 20 percent in seventh, 15 percent in eighth and in high school).
- Ronfeldt, M., & McQueen, K. (2017). “Does New Teacher Induction Really Improve Retention?” Journal of Teacher Education, 68(4), 394-410.
- Ingersoll, R. M., & Strong, M. (2011). “The Impact of Induction and Mentoring Programs for Beginning Teachers: A Critical Review of the Research.” Review of Educational Research, 81(2), 201-233.
- Professional Association of Georgia Educators (2025). Workforce Survey, May 2025: 3,408 educators from 177 districts. Top retention strategies named by respondents: increase salaries, reduce class size, protect teacher planning time.
- Texas Education Agency data as reported by the Houston Chronicle: Houston ISD teacher turnover of 32.2 percent in 2024-25 against 18.8 percent statewide, following the 2023 requirement that teachers at the district’s 28 New Education System campuses reapply for their positions.
- Pearman, F. (2026). Getting Down to Facts III, Stanford Graduate School of Education: school closures across California districts, 2011-2019, reduced per pupil spending by about $447 and revenue by about $433, with average enrollment losses of about 287 students per closure.
- El Paso Independent School District (2026): salaried central office staff, about 255 employees including the superintendent, required to substitute teach eight days per year, with projected substitute savings of about $255,000.
Keep the watchdog independent
If this article saved you money, time, or a headache, if you enjoyed it, or if you want to support local investigative journalism, you can buy me a coffee by card. No account needed, and Ko-fi takes no cut, so it all goes to the work.
Prefer steady support? Join the Patreon for monthly backing.



